Six Months In, GDPR’s Impact Uncertain In the U.S.
We’ve barely scratched the surface on the impacts of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), the far-reaching European Union law that went into effect six months ago. As European law enforcement organizations prepare their first cases against Google, it appears that some organizations in the United States are taking a wait-and-see approach to GDPR compliance.
Formal complaints were filed by seven EU countries against Google last week for a purported violation of GDPR with its Android operating system. Apparently, users cannot turn off GPS tracking by disabling the “Location History” option. Instead, they must also disable “Web and App Activity,” which are enabled by default. Because no consent was given to be tracked, all this constitutes a violation of GDPR, according to European regulators.
“Google’s data hunger is notorious but the scale with which it deceives its users to track and monetise their every move is breathtaking,” states Monique Goyens, director general of the European consumer organization (BEUC), said in a press release. “Google’s deceptive practices are in breach of the spirit and the letter of this regulation. We need strong, coherent, enforcement of the rules. We can’t have companies pretending to comply but de facto circumventing the law.”
If Google is found in violation of the GDPR, it could be fined up to 4% of its annual revenue, which would be $4 billion. A Portuguese hospital appears to be the organization with the dubious title of receiving the first GDPR fine from the EU, in this case €400,000.
But the Web giants were odds-on favorites to receive the most attention under GDPR, and reality appears to be living up to the hype. Facebook could face charges of violating GDPR as a result of the way it handled the data breach that occurred earlier this year that compromised more than 50 million accounts. Under GDPR rules, organizations must notify regulators of the breach within 72 hours of discovering its existence. Facebook says it made the notifications within that timeframe, but the Irish privacy commissioner is reportedly still seeking information.
Other companies have also been referred to authorities for GDPR violations, although no formal complaints have been filed by regulators. Last month, Privacy International accused Oracle, Acxiom, Experian, Equifax, and three ad-tech firms of violating GDPR. “Part of their business models are about fundamentally exploiting data and therefore clash with many of the provisions [of the EU’s General Data Protection Regulation],” Privacy International legal officer Ailidh Callander told Financial Times.
Uber received a GDPR-style fine this year for how it handled a data breach. The ride-sharing firm was fined $158 million this year by attorneys general in all 50 states (plus Washington D.C.) for attempting to cover up a 2016 data breach that impacted 57 million customers, including some in Europe. The firm was subsequently fined smaller amounts by privacy commissioners in the Netherlands and the UK, although it was not a GDPR fine because the violation happened in 2016.
The fine, which amounted to 2.4% of Uber’s 2016 revenues, was seen by some as a GDPR-esque shot over the bow of a large tech firm by American regulators. “Uber’s decision to cover up this breach was a blatant violation of the public’s trust,” said California Attorney General Xavier Becerra.
California has been on the frontline of the battle over who controls data and consumers’ rights to privacy and security. Just after GDPR went into effect this spring, Governor Jerry Brown signed the California Consumer Privacy Act of 2018 into law. The law, which goes into effect in 2020, has been dubbed “GDPR Lite.”
However, besides California, few other states seem to have the appetite to take on established technology interests by passing GDPR-style data protection laws. Even after Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg and other tech titans testified before Congress earlier this year following the Cambridge Analytical scandal, there is no coalition of voices calling for greater regulation of data. US Senator Ron Wyden of Oregon submitted a GDPR-like privacy bill, but it stalled in the House.
Against this backdrop, it’s curious that Apple CEO Tim Cook has been so outspoken about the need for data privacy in the United States. “Our own information, from the everyday to the deeply personal, is being weaponized against us with military efficiency,” Cook said during a speech in Brussels earlier this year. “It is time for the rest of the world, including my home country, to follow your lead.”
While the American tech giants work to ensure they don’t run afoul of GDPR when it comes to EU citizens who use their services, the same cannot be said of all US companies. By some accounts, large firms in the US are doing just the bare minimum to be able to check the GDPR box.
Fouad Khalil, the compliance director at SSH Communications Security, took several unnamed US publications to task for putting their old business models ahead of compliance. “Several prominent US publications are currently inaccessible to EU-based readers,” Khalil wrote in an article in the Silicon Republic. “These organisations have apparently made a judgement call that their business model is better off shedding international readers than investing in compliance.”
Surveys show that 70% of companies around the world are not GPDR compliant, which shouldn’t come as as surprise, considering how many different aspects there are to GDPR compliance, and the fact that addressing each one of them takes time.
“Customers are still working on it, first of all,” says Stan Christiaens, co-founder and CTO of Collibra, which develops data governance solutions. “They realize it’s a big initiative, and it’s taking a lot of work.”
The first wave of GDPR remediation largely involved organizations adding check boxes to their websites and other forms of communications with customers, Christiaens says. It’s a good start, but it’s not nearly enough. Full GDPR remediation will require organizations to make invasive changes to their business processes and – most importantly – change their business cultures.
One of the most effective ways that companies can change their data cultures is by hiring a chief data officer (CDO), he says. That’s how banks started getting a handle on some of the new digital regulations that were foisted upon their earlier this decade, and it’s how organizations in other industries will survive GDPR too.
The bigger question for Christiaens, however, revolves around consumer sentiment. If people don’t demand that companies take better care of their data, then it’s likely nothing will change. Making people aware of what companies are doing with their data is the best way to force change.
“People don’t know their data exhaust online is exposing them to all sorts of ranking and ratings that effect their lives. They just don’t underhand or see those connections,” he says. “Everybody is pointing the finger at China. They say, ‘Oh the social credit system in China, you won’t be able to take a bus any more if you don’t behave.’
“But the same exact thing is happening in the US,” he continues. “If you submit your resume for a job interview, in the background a social media check is happening. You don’t even know it’s happening. You apply for a loan and based on skin color — because the bias is encoded in the algorithm — you get it or you don’t, or your interest is higher or lower. All of these effects are completely hidden and in-transparent to people.”
October 11, 2019
- Stanley, Black & Decker Selects DataRobot to Supersize Data Science Efforts
- Talend Cloud Now Available on Microsoft Azure
- Igneous DataProtect Now Available on AWS Marketplace
October 10, 2019
- Diveplane’s GEMINAI Enables Organizations to Safely Share, Sell and Analyze Datasets
- UC Berkeley Launches Data Science Minor Program
- Neo4j Launches Program to Empower Educators
- Hitachi Vantara Expands Lumada Portfolio to Accelerate Data Innovation Through DataOps
- Intelligent Waves Awarded $89M Contract for Crowd-Sourced Data Support
- Domo’s New Solution to Help Merchants with Multiple Square Accounts Unlock Real-Time Business Insights
- Anaconda Appoints Peter Wang as CEO
- Hitachi Vantara Partners with Disney Parks to Advance the Next Generation of Ride and Show Analytics
October 9, 2019
- Syniti Unveils Knowledge-Based Advanced Data Migration Cloud Software
- Kinetica’s Active Analytics Platform is Now Available in the Oracle Cloud Marketplace
- Report: European Companies Moving to Cloud Lagging on Security
- Fujitsu Launches New Stream Data Processing Platform to Accelerate Use of Automotive Big Data
October 8, 2019
- ActiveViam Launches Data Lab to Help Companies Find Insights into Their Markets
- Syncsort Adds Event Management Support to Ironstream for ServiceNow
- Assurance Financial Partners with Domo to Unlock Customer Journey Data
- Dynatrace Expands Software Intelligence Platform with Digital Business Analytics
- GoodData to Leverage Amazon Redshift to Help Enterprise and Product Teams Deliver Analytics Solutions
Most Read Features
- What’s the Difference Between AI, ML, Deep Learning, and Active Learning?
- Kafka Transforming Into ‘Event Streaming Database’
- Big Data File Formats Demystified
- Is Python Strangling R to Death?
- Cloudera Begins New Cloud Era with CDP Launch
- Can We Stop Doing ETL Yet?
- 10 Big Data Trends to Watch in 2019
- Hadoop Has Failed Us, Tech Experts Say
- How to Build a Better Machine Learning Pipeline
- Is Hadoop Officially Dead?
- More Features…
Most Read News In Brief
- Kafka Spawns Open-Source KarelDB
- California’s New Data Privacy Law Takes Effect in 2020
- HPE Acquires MapR
- War Unfolding for Control of Elasticsearch
- Global DataSphere to Hit 175 Zettabytes by 2025, IDC Says
- What to Expect at Strata This Week
- MapR Says It’s Close to Deal to Sell Company
- Gartner: Augmented Analytics Ready for Prime Time
- Presto Moves Under Linux Umbrella
- IBM Adds Kubernetes Operator for CouchDB
- More News In Brief…
Most Read This Just In
- Datanami Announces 2019 Readers’ and Editors’ Choice Award Winners
- New Cloudera Study Shows Current Enterprise Data Strategies Ineffective
- Aerospike Now Supports Intel Ethernet 800 Series with Application Device Queues Technology
- ArangoDB Extends Open Source Solution with ArangoML Pipeline
- Databricks Partners with Tableau: Enabling Organizations To Run Business Intelligence on Data Lakes Faster and More Reliably
- Aimia Selects H2O.ai Driverless AI for its Customer Loyalty Programs
- Syncsort Survey Reveals Disconnect Between Data Trust and Data Quality
- Biogen Chooses Lexalytics to Improve Customer Care with New AI-Based Text Analytics System
- TIBCO Announces Beta Program for its Cloud-Native Enterprise Metadata Solution
- DataVisor Named a Global Leader in Cloud Computing
- More This Just In…
October 20 - October 22Charlotte NC United States
October 23 - October 24Berlin Germany