Analytics Show Facebook Coddling Trump’s Falsehoods
Former president and formerly prolific tweeter Donald Trump has been banned from most major social media sites since the days following the attack on the U.S. Capitol. In the intervening weeks, many of those sites have been forced to grapple with Trump’s extensive litany of falsehoods that were, until the last weeks of his presidency, by and large amplified by their platforms. Currently, one of those platforms – Facebook – is on the verge of announcing whether or not they will lift restrictions on Trump’s account. Ahead of that announcement, The Markup has published an analysis of Facebook’s handling of false posts, concluding that Facebook generally treated falsehoods with “kid gloves” – particularly when it came to Trump’s.
The analysis used The Markup’s Citizen Browser project, which uses a desktop app to regularly collect HTML source code and screenshots of Facebook feeds from a diverse panel of participants across the U.S. That data – which excludes personal messages and the users’ actual browsing information – is then anonymized, uploaded to the cloud, and analyzed.
During the period in question – December 2020 to February 2021 – The Markup’s roughly 2,200 panelists’ feeds included 682 flagged posts: that is, posts that were “false, devoid of context, or related to an especially controversial issue.” However, 588 of these were automatic flags pinned on virtually anything election-related.
Of the remaining posts, a measly 12 were explicitly labeled “false,” while 38 were flagged under the far-vaguer label “missing context.” Many posts containing demonstrable lies received non-committal automatic flags urging caution rather than explicit fact-checks, and overall, older Americans and Trump voters were more likely to encounter these weakly flagged posts.
The chief flag-ee among the sample was, of course, Donald Trump. However, of the 12 posts that were marked “false,” none belonged to Trump, despite his repeated posts suggesting that President Biden’s win was statistically impossible, illegal, and so on.
Facebook, for its part, has argued that it is not its place to “referee political debates and prevent a politician’s speech from reaching its audience.” However, Facebook also claimed that it warned users when they attempted to share flagged content – which, when The Markup tested this functionality, it didn’t. After being asked about this incongruity, Facebook added the warning it had promised.
“My guess would be that Facebook doesn’t fact-check Donald Trump not because of a concern for free speech or democracy, but because of a concern for their bottom line,” Ethan Porter, an assistant professor in the School of Media and Public Affairs at George Washington University, told The Markup. “They’ve chosen not to aggressively fact-check. As a result, more people believe false things than would otherwise, full stop.”
September 23, 2021
- AtScale Expands Semantic Layer Solution for Microsoft Excel
- CNCF End User Technology Radar Provides Insights into DevSecOps
- At Annual OCEANS 2021, Sofar Ocean Debuts First-of-Its-Kind Maritime Open Standard, Bristlemouth
- Elastic Announces the General Availability of Elastic App Search Web Crawler, New Features for Elastic Enterprise Search
- Securonix Achieves FedRAMP In-Process Authorization
- EDJX and Cubic Corporation Partner to Launch the Internet of Military Things Edge Platform
September 22, 2021
- GigaOm Names Moogsoft an Industry Leader in “Radar for AIOps Solutions” Report
- Clearsense Acquires Plug-and-Play AI Analytics Firm
- Purdue University Global Launches Master of Science in Data Analytics
- Dihuni OptiReady CognitX Deep Learning Servers and Workstations Powered by NVIDIA Ampere Architecture-based GPUs
- Scality Awarded New U.S. Patent for Breakthrough Technology in Hyper-Scale Data Protection
- MicroAI to Bring AI Training to Renesas MCUs
- Recent Gartner VP Analyst Sanjeev Mohan Joins Okera as a Strategic Advisor
- C3 AI Reinvents Enterprise Software UX With C3 AI Data Vision
September 21, 2021
- Healthcare Analytics Summit 21 Virtual Kicks Off Today
- Tesco Selects Teradata Vantage to Drive Enterprise-Wide Analytics at Scale
- Ketch Secures $20 Million in Series A1 Funding, Accelerating its Rapid Growth
- Yandex Spins Off ClickHouse into Standalone Company
- Analytics Vidhya Announces $5.5 Million Strategic Investment from Fractal, Aims to Train Half a Million Full Stack AI Professionals
- Nutanix Cloud Platform Breaks Down Silos in Hybrid Multicloud Operations
Most Read Features
- One on One with Google Cloud Product Director Irina Farooq
- Big Data File Formats Demystified
- Tabular Seeks to Remake Cloud Data Lakes in Iceberg’s Image
- What’s the Difference Between AI, ML, Deep Learning, and Active Learning?
- Who’s Winning In the $17B AIOps and Observability Market
- SambaNova Brings Custom Silicon To Bear on High-End AI Workloads
- In Search of the Modern Data Stack
- COVID-Driven Cloud Surge Takes a Toll on the Data
- Rethinking Education in an AI-First World
- Did Rockset Just Solve Real-Time Analytics?
- More Features…
Most Read News In Brief
- LinkedIn Open Sources Tech Behind 10,000-Node Hadoop Cluster
- Data and AI Salaries Continue Upward March, O’Reilly Says
- Gartner Shuffles the Technology Deck with Latest ‘Hype Cycle’ Report
- Data Prep Still Dominates Data Scientists’ Time, Survey Finds
- Who’s Winning in Open Source Data Tech
- Can Apple Right its Privacy and Security Cart?
- Hands-Off: Manual Data Integration Tasks Plummeting, Gartner Says
- Why Is SAS Going Public?
- Apollo CEO Bullish on GraphQL’s Potential in the Enterprise
- Why Young Developers Don’t Get Knowledge Graphs
- More News In Brief…
Most Read This Just In
- TIBCO NOW 2021 Showcases Limitless Power of Data
- Cribl Raises $200M in Series C Funding on Traction with Global Enterprise Customers
- Toloka Launches Data Research Grants, Announces First Eight Recipients
- Anaconda Announces Support for Pyston, Hiring Lead Developers Kevin Modzelewski and Marius Wachtler
- MariaDB Announces SIS Provider Campus Cloud Services Migration to MariaDB SkySQL
- Transaction Processing Performance Council (TPC) Launches an Artificial Intelligence Benchmark (TPCx-AI)
- Kinetica Fuses Streaming and Contextual Analysis At Scale
- Hewlett Packard Enterprise Wins $2B HPE GreenLake Contract with NSA
- CalypsoAI Announces Partnership with ECS to Develop Solutions for Trustworthy AI
- DataRobot Launches “DataRobot AI Cloud” Platform
- More This Just In…
Sponsored Partner Content
October 5 - October 7
October 12 - October 14
October 19London United Kingdom
October 27 - October 28
November 29 - December 3
December 6 - December 10San Diego CA United States